I found the final chapters of Goldstein's book to be much more interesting than the first portion. Here he discusses the difficulty in measuring war and looks at whether it has been increasing or decreasing worldwide. Though trends show that overall war deaths are decreasing, improved technology has provided us with extensive media access to violent reports and data.According to Goldstein, the world is more peaceful place today than it was during and prior to the cold-war era, but we have an innate bias for current events, and they feel more important than historical violence and wars. Society is drawn to violent images and reports. Although these may only represent the rare cases within a war, they make for very interesting stories. Take for example the recent shooting of Afghan civilians, a story that made worldwide news, today weeks after the event, stories about it are making the headlines. We are rarely exposed to the positive changes created as a result of war (if any) This is something I would consider researching for our second paper, what improvements have been made in either Afghanistan or Iraq as a result of the current war/U.S. intervention?
The majority of stories in the media related to these wars/interventions have been of death and destruction, likely because this is what sells newspapers. But
to what extent has quality of life improved in any of these regions as a result of the war?
Goldstein explains how democracy, free trade, and economic interests promote peace. In his opinion, International organizations, like the United Nations are the most vital reason for an increase in worldwide peace. But economic interests, may be what is truly bringing nations together.
Overall, I appreciate how Goldstein explained the causes and varying forms of war. As mentioned in class, he does have a strong bias for the United Nations and even suggests how we should support them. His focus is on the "big picture" and the numbers that demonstrate his point: the world is a more peaceful place today than it was 60 years ago (which he would attribute to the work of the U.N.)
Research: What are the indirect causes of civilian war deaths?
Quiz: What is the ratio of civilian-to-military war deaths over the past hundred years?
Great job Jillian! I was wondering if anyone felt the same way I did about the last portion of the book, and now I am relieved to find I'm not the only one who thinks that the media hypes up war to improve ratings? I also was pleased to read your idea for the next paper, which was similar to my idea and research question posed earlier in class about a study on how much has NAFTA really helped the people of Mexico? I really enjoyed this book as well, and am glad I'm not the only one who is keeping up with every writing assignment, as I had a slighty difficult time finding someone who even wrote about the last chapters of the book. Thank you!
ReplyDelete