Film Review: Inside North Korea

Name: Jillian Garcia
Title of Movie: National Geographic-Inside North Korea
Film Setting North Korea
Actual Filming Location: North Korea
Reference: Natgeo.com & film credits
Inside North Korea is a 2007 National Geographic film that gives a glimpse at life inside the mysterious country. American Reporter Lisa Ling follows a Nepalese Surgeon taking part in a humanitarian mission; restoring vision to North Koreans who have suffered blindness due to cataracts. The American reporter was granted access into the country by concealing her investigative intentions and posing as a Health Worker assisting in the humanitarian effort. The film offers a gloomy look at life under Kim Jung Il’s leadership, exposing the extreme and ultimate power the leader held over his people.
The “Supreme Leader” demonstrates social control in all aspects of North Korean life including media, education, military, employment, housing, and criminal justice. Government minders ensure that outsiders see only what the government wishes them to see, outsiders are allowed to travel only to government authorized locations under the close supervision of minders. In Pyongyang, a city populated by millions, public places including streets and parks appear empty of city residents; though a strong military presence is evident everywhere. The film makers are allowed to interview only citizens selected by the government, who profess love and loyalty for their leader. The Surgeon performing the eye surgeries is allowed to operate on a portion of the population hand selected by the government. Interestingly, these people suffered from blindness caused by cataracts that in a place with sufficient healthcare could have been easily treated and prevented. Upon removal of their bandages and restoration of their vision they demonstrate immense gratitude, not for the surgeon who helped them, but rather for their “supreme leader” Kim Jong Il and his father the former leader Kim Il Sung. In one disturbing scene at the closing of the film, after being restored his vision a man proclaims to a portrait of his leader “with these eyes I’ve received I will grab a gun and kill every one of the American enemies and terminate them from the earth!”
The primary intent of the film is to expose the great amount of social control imposed upon North Koreans by their leader and former leader. It succeeds at this and also serves to make the viewer a bit uncomfortable closing with an image of a bomb and the statement “what happens here can directly touch everyone in the world.”
The film connects to many of the topics covered within our class. In Joshua Goldstein’s Winning the War on War, he lists the deadliest wars of our history, the Korean War falls in the top 3, with over a million war related deaths. Goldstein describes how the North Korean government has killed millions more of its own citizens in the years that have passed since the end of the war. Goldstein attributes many of the deaths to placement in government run concentration camps. The horrific conditions of Camp 22, said to contain thousands of North Koreans, is depicted in the film. A former guard is interviewed; he explains how the small act of complaining about government rations can land not only an individual but also his entire family in a concentration camp, for life. Within the camp, guards report to have been trained to administer severe and cruel punishment upon prisoners. Surprisingly, Kim Jong Il is said to have denied the existence of these and similar camps.
Susan Brewers book Why America Fights focuses on propaganda and how it has been used as a tool by the U.S. government to persuade citizens to support their actions. Inside North Korea exposes the excessive use of propaganda by the North Korean government, propaganda runs throughout all forms of media including radio, television, and art. Loyalty to their leader and his beliefs is a strict requirement that if not followed can result in death, not only of the individual but also of his/her family. Government employees, called minders present only a certain version of the country to outsiders, which consist of books authored by their leader and artwork depicting their leaders. They went as far as to construct a propaganda town at their border with South Korea consisting of beautiful empty buildings. A town solely created for the purpose of attracting South Korean defectors to the North.
The concept of a failed state where the government is not meeting the basic needs of its citizens was a topic discussed throughout Christian Parenti’s book Tropic of Chaos. North Korea appears to be a failed state, though their government is said to provide housing, education, and food for the citizens, military growth and development are the ultimate priority As recently as the 1990s they suffered a famine. The film presents a large portion of the population suffering from malnutrition and poor healthcare, as well as children who have suffered from growth problems due to lack of nutrition. Although the North Korean government may be succeeding in providing housing and education, they appear to be falling very short in the areas of healthcare and rations. Their leader holds absolute power but does not complete his responsibilities in providing for the people.
After reading Why America Fights, I was left curious about the current situation in North Korea. The book explained that after the Korean War, Communism prevailed in the North whereas South Korea eventually established a Democracy. I wondered whether or not they still lived in a Communist society or if they had moved more towards a Democracy. I was unsure of what to expect viewing the film, and went into it with an open-mind. I learned that North Koreans follow an ideology that runs in contrast to most modern societies. They follow a model of self-reliance, which has served to isolate them from much of the outside world
The film appears by all means to be credible, relying heavily upon interviews with North Koreans currently living in the country, as well as defectors who have fled the country. My only criticism would be of the sinister music that plays throughout the film, exposing the film maker’s bias against the North Korean government. I was completely surprised to see the tremendous power and dominance the government imposes upon the people. It is very difficult to comprehend the extreme loyalty and respect held for their leader, the now deceased Kim Jong Il. Those interviewed, praised him with great passion; I was left wondering if perhaps it was the result of brainwashing, fear, or true pride in their leader. In all, it was a fascinating film that provides a look at a society very different from our own.