Half the Sky -Group Discussion

Geog 112-02
Half the Sky
Group Discussion

Jillian Garcia
Greg Hardesty
Kristin Radford
Kyle Morrow


Ch.6 Maternal Mortality
In chapter 6 Nicholas Kristoff and Sheryl WuDunn introduce us to Mahabouba Muhammad, an Ethiopian woman, sold for the equivalent  of $10 at the age of 13 to a man many years her senior. She was purchased as a second wife. Mahabouba endured rape and beatings, only once she became pregnant did the violence temporarily cease. She was able to escape but found no support in nearby villages, she faced stigma as a pregnant runaway. Soon after she was taken in by an uncle, but could not afford a midwife to deliver her child.
Mahabouba was a teenage girl, alone, enduring the pain of childbirth. Because of her young age, and her underdeveloped pelvis, the baby could not make it through the birth canal.. After a week of labor, her baby died in the womb and  she had lost control of her bladder and bowels. She suffered from obstetric fistula as a result of her obstructed labor. Sadly, if she would have received adequate medical care, her fetus could have lived,and the maternal injury that she suffered would have been avoided through medical intervention. In the West women that suffer from obstructed labor are able to undergo a c-section, and fistulas are completely preventable.Fistulas are a problem in parts of the world where women have no access to medical care, and if left untreated can result in death from infection. With the help of a foreign missionary Mahabouba would eventually make it to The Fistula Hospital in Addis Ababa, where she would be treated. The Hospital was established by Dr. Catherine Hamlin and has treated thousands of women.
Kristoff and WuDunn argue that Maternal care is not a priority, while women are dying during childbirth every minute, nations focus larger portions of their overall spending on other priorities. Sierra Lione and Niger are cited as having the highest maternal mortality rates in the world. Overall women in sub-saharan Africa face very high risk levels of injury and death during childbirth.

Ch. 7 Why Do Women Die in Childbirth?
This chapter exposes both the immediate and gradual causes of maternal mortality. The major immediate causes of death during childbirth are hemorrhage, malaria,obstructed labor, and abortion related complications but there are also indirect causes that are due to larger societal issues.
They share the devastating story of Prudence, a Cameroonian woman whose death at the age of 24 can be attributed to both biological and societal issues.. The first being an obstructed uterus dues to a fatal mistake made by an untrained birthing assistant. Other factors that contributed to the death of Prudence and her unborn baby were lack of maternal education or family planning which would have prepared her for labor and encouraged medical care. A very poor health system that did not have antibiotics available to treat infection is partially responsible for her death as well. The underlying issue that has brought about the death of Prudence and countless others is an overall disregard for the needs and rights of women.
Campaigns against maternal mortality are underway in places like Sri Lanka but the issue requires much more world attention and funding. Sri Lanka has lowered their maternal mortality rate by training a large numbers of midwives and allowing them to provide much needed prenatal care and physician referrals for high risk patients. In Sri Lanka health care has been made available to pregnant women and has shown great results.

Discussion Questions
Kristoff and WuDunn argue that America should lead the way in fighting maternal mortality, do  you agree?
Prior to reading the book how aware were you of issues surrounding maternal mortality?
why do you think that is?

Ch.8: Family Planning and the “God Gulf
The beginning of chapter 8 tells the story of Rose Wanjera, a 26 year old women in Kenya, whom has a small child and another on the way. Kristoff and Dunn explain that she appeared at a clinic due to the fact that she was sick and has received no prenatal care. Her story is unusual as she is “college educated and spoke English very well”. As this unfortunate story turns out, Rose is told by the doctor that she had an infection that could threaten not only her life, but the baby’s as well. The book ties this situation to the gag rule that was implemented by George Bush that barres any funds to any foreign aid group that counseled women about abortion options or had any link to abortions. Kristoff also explains that due to the lack of funding within the clinic, 80 doctors and nurses were laid off.
We are introduced to another character, Thabang, a 14 year old South African girl who was born to a family that has had the unfortunate outbreak of AIDS. Thabang, however, does not have the virus and can be classified as an unruly teenager who hates her mother Gertrude. Kristoff and Dunn explain that the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Poverty Action Lab have been working on four different strategies against AIDS. One strategy was to train elementary school teachers in AIDS education and only cost about two dollars per student, but ultimately had no reduction in pregnancy. The second approach was about a dollar per student which encouraged the use of condoms, which had a reduce to pregnancies. The third approach was the most expensive, which was to provide each student with a school uniform to encourage them to stay in school longer, and costs about twelve dollars per day and saw a reduction in pregnancies. The fourth approach was the most cost effective which was telling the students all of the warnings of sugar daddies, and had the greatest reduction of teen pregnancies.

Chapter Nine: Women in Afghan Culture
Chapter nine addresses the issues surrounding women’s freedom and education in Middle Eastern countries. Of the countries where women are held back and subjected to systematic abuses such as honor killings and genital cutting, a very large proportion are predominately Muslim, and 10 of the bottom 12 countries ranked on ‘status of women’ were majority Muslim. Although many people are quick to blame these trends on fundamentalist Islam beliefs, these attitudes arise from culture, although people do quote from the Koran to justify their actions. The Koran was actually a step forward for women because it banned female infanticide, limited polygamy to four wives, and allowed women to own property. At this time, many other religions were more restrictive towards women, but those have since progressed, while Islam has stayed the same. Sadly, a result of this stubbornness is that females are suffering; for example, fourteen girls were burned to death in a school fire when they were forced by religious police back into the school building because they were not wearing the proper coverings and therefore could not go outside. Luckily, Islamic feminists are on the rise, and they are looking to change the meanings people give to the teachings of the Koran. These women are strong, and feel that Westerners are patronizing.
Part of the chapter is dedicated to explaining the conditions women face daily in Afghan culture. The Women’s Detention Center in Kabul, Afghanistan is where teenage girls and young women are jailed when they fail their ‘hymen test’. Although this seems extreme, this is sometimes the safest place for these women because the backlash they experience from their family can be deadly. As the book states, jail is sometimes the safest place for a bold Afghan woman. Although the situation may seem hopeless, there are many people willing and able to help. Sakena is a woman who started a system of underground girls’ schools during Taliban rule. Since the Taliban fell, she has expanded and now serves 350,000 women and children with medical care and education. Educating women is the most effective way to overcome terrorism and violence in these countries.


Ch.10 Investing in Education
Chapter 10 starts off by telling a story about Dai Manju. Dai was a small 13 year old girl who was living in a rural village in the Dabie mountains of central China. She loved going to school and learning about new things but was unable to continue on to the 6th grade because her parents couldn’t afford sending her to school. The school fee was $13 a year which seemed like a waste of money to her parents. The family barely had enough money to live off of, for example they could only afford to eat meat once a year for the Chinese New Year. Dai lived in a small wooden shack with her mother, father, two brothers, her great aunt, and a large pig.
When Kristof and WuDunn wrote an article about Dai and her family in 1990 a reader from New York donated $10,000 to the villages school program to help girls like Dai be able to attend school as long as they want. Once the village got the money they immediately build a new school and gave and gave all the girls in the village scholarships. With all of the improvements being made in the city, Kristoff decided to call the the donor to report all of the changes being made. However, they soon found out that the donor only donated $100 not $10,000. Fortunately for the village, the bank that made the error decided that they would cover the other $9,900 of the donation. This generosity  gave Dai the chance to finish elementary school, middle school, high school, and the equivalent of an accounting school.
Dai was able to find a job in a nearby city where she was able to make a good amount of money. She sent money back to her family which quickly made them the richest in their village. When Kristof returned to visit them a few years later the family had a six room concrete house with electricity, a stove, TV, and fan. Kristof calls this the power of education, which is the main topic of chapter 10.
Kristof and WuDunn discuss different ways to boost girls attendance rate in schools around the world. One way they discuss is to deworm students. deworming is a cost effective way to increase attendance by almost 25% in some parts of the world. On average, an American will spend upwards of $50 to deworm their pets; in Africa you can spend 50 cents and deworm a child. Another cost effective way Kristof talks about is helping young girls with their menstruation. A study found that many african girls will tend to stay home during those times.  A third option, is to help women obtain the correct amount of iodine. Insignificant amounts of Iodine has been proven to lower a child's IQ by 15%.
Kristof and WuDunn discuss some of the issues companies and donors face when trying to provide aid to people around the world. They discuss how in America an idea can seem incredibly simple when in reality it is extremely complex and difficult. They give an example of a pregnant woman in Africa with HIV. Even if she gets tested for HIV, and then goes to a hospital to deliver her baby, and the hospital has nevirapine (a drug that protects babies from infection during childbirth) and even if the hospital has the efficiency to administer it and even if the woman is told not to breastfeed her child, and even if the hospital gives her a free supply of infant formula, the system will fail because the women feel that if they feed their babies through a bottle the other people living in the town will realize she has HIV and ostracize her.

Discussion Question: Which strategy will boost women's attendance the most and why?