Abstract
Despite the vast amount of research
on the Vietnam War little is known of the children that were produced and often
orphaned as a result of the war. Thousands of Vietnamese and Vietnamese
Amerasian children in South Vietnam faced an unknown future under the North
Vietnamese Communist takeover. Rumors spread that children fathered by American
GI’s would be brutally murdered at the hands of the North Vietnamese regime.
American sponsored orphanages throughout South Vietnam urged the United States
Government to intervene with the removal of orphans from Saigon. In April of 1975 President Gerald Ford
authorized for thousands of children to be removed from Vietnam and transported
to the United States for adoption. The saving of small children united an
American public that had been left dissatisfied with the results of the War. The
idea of rescuing innocent infants and children brought an outpouring of
support. Over 2,000 children made it to
U.S. soil but thousands more did not. Those mix-raced children left in Vietnam
faced an uncertain fate. This study analyzes multiple perspectives on the Baby
lift operations. I will examine biographical accounts of the families involved,
both in the United States and Vietnam, observing the adversities faced in both
countries. In addition, I plan to research articles of the time period that
evaluate the American Government’s tactics and motivation. My work will
contribute to a better understanding of one aspect the Vietnam War, The Baby lift
children brought to America and those who remained in Vietnam.
Baby lifts and
the Forgotten Children of the Vietnam War
The last U.S.
combat troops officially departed from Vietnam in 1973, after the signing of a
ceasefire. With that, U.S. aid to the South decreased significantly, 2 years
later the North would launch an aggressive attack on the South, cities and
provinces fell one by one. By April 1975, the Communist backed Northern
Vietnamese had captured Danang, and Saigon was next to fall as they moved south.
The war-torn country was in a state of panic as rumors spread about the harsh
treatment southerners would face at the hands of the Communists. Meanwhile, the
war torn countries’ orphanages were overwhelmed with children. The children were left at orphanages for
various reasons. Some had lost their parents in the war. Others were abandoned by
families that could not provide for them, due to high levels of poverty. A
large portion of children were those of mixed-race, fathered by American
soldiers, whose families feared that they would be harmed by the Northern
Vietnamese. The final group consisted of children who were temporarily turned
over by their mothers to orphanages, mothers who expected for their children to
be returned to them after the war.
There was a rush
to get the children out of Vietnam. Humanitarian organizations and Politicians
pleaded with the U.S Government to remove orphaned children. In a statement by
U.S. Representative Paul Tsongas, he expressed the urgency of the issue, “ The present
situation in Vietnam is
the culmination of a
series of tragic
mistakes in American
policy. While we
have no obligation
to contribute one more penny to
the Thieu regime, we
have every obligation
to offer humanitarian assistance
to the orphans
of Vietnam”(Tsongas 1975). President
Gerald Ford would allocate $2 million dollars to a foreign aid fund authorizing
the United States Military, with the help of adoption agencies to begin
shipping Vietnamese children out of the area. They were to be airlifted to the
United States, Australia and Canada for adoption. The Vietnamese baby lifts
were the result of a humanitarian effort but errors in execution and lack of planning
would create controversy and mixed results for the children and families
involved.
A Tragic Beginning
Numbers vary, but in total approximately 3,000
children were flown out of Vietnam as part of the Baby lifts. American
sponsored orphanages played a large role in carrying out the mission. Aid
workers form Holt International, Friends for All Children and Catholic Relief
Services cared for the children before and during the flights. The U.S. would
designate the largest available military cargo planes for the operation.
The very first
flight left Saigon on April 4, 1975 carrying 330 adults and children. The
flight never made it out of Vietnam, crashing within minutes of departure, as
the result of a mechanical failure. The crash took the lives of 138 adults and
children on board. Survivors of the crash were promptly placed on flights in
the following days. These babies and young children survived multiple traumas
in a matter of a few days. First being separated from the life they knew, and
then living through a tragic crash. The plane crash made headline news in
America, and the plight of the orphans gained widespread attention and support.
Americans long divided by the War in Vietnam seemed to unite behind the
humanitarian effort to save the children of the war.
Controversy
Like the war
itself, the Baby lift was very controversial. Once children began arriving in
the U.S. and the details of the airlifts began to surface, it became evident
that some of the children had no documentation to confirm who they were, or whether
or not they were truly orphans. Because the children were rapidly evacuated
over a period of a few weeks, documents containing their birth parents
information may have been lost, destroying ties to their families in Vietnam. Many wondered whether or not the children
would have been better off raised in their country of birth. In Vietnam, the
Northern Government accused Americans of kidnap, denouncing the airlifts.
Some skeptical
Americans questioned President Ford’s decision to remove the children from
Vietnam, viewing it as an effort for America to prove that something positive
came out of the War. In large numbers, the
American public demonstrated great sympathy and generosity offering their time and assistance to help the
children establish a new life. But the airlifts also perpetuated an idea of
American superiority by intervening and changing the course of people’s lives
without considering the possible repercussions. The International Red Cross
spoke out against the mass evacuations. As revealed in a 1975 Time Magazine article “the U.S. is in
violation of the Geneva Conventions requirement that war orphans be educated in
their home country” (Time 1975).
After the chaos in
Vietnam settled, birth mothers who had turned their children over to orphanages
for care and had immigrated to the U.S. in search of their kids. Some were able
to locate them and legally regain custody. Others were up against a confusing
legal system, and had little to no paperwork linking them to their children. A
class action law suit was filed by The Center for Constitutional Rights on
behalf of the adoptees requesting that each of their cases be reviewed, as to
determine whether they were all valid orphans. The lawsuit contended “the
children were taken from South Vietnam against the will of their
parents”(Martin p.7) In her book The
Life we were Given, Dana Sachs reveals that after a year long investigation “The
I.N.S found that at least 10% of the children were not true orphans, therefore
ineligible for adoption.” (Sachs p.208) Even with that important discovery, the
case was thrown out, and the U.S. government allowed children to remain with
their American placements. If birthmothers or families wished for their children
back, they were required to file individual cases. Many years would be spent
fighting for the chance to get children back, and only some mothers were
successful in their attempts to reunite with their children.
A
New Life
A
large portion of the American public stood behind the mission and volunteered
to take-in the children. Those in
support of the operation argued that the children were better off in the U.S.
with the belief that life under Communist rule would be difficult for anyone, especially
orphans and children of mixed American heritage.
A
portion of the children were already in the process of being adopted, prior to
the fall of Saigon. For these children, a new family awaited them upon arrival
to the U.S. The airlifts served to expedite the lengthy process of foreign
adoption by removing the red-tape surrounding it. The Baby lifts meant a new life for those who
made it onto the evacuating flights, but an even larger portion of the children
were not flown out. Author Dana Sachs explains, “In Saigon alone, over 20,000
children remained in orphanages” (Sachs 29). Overall, the baby lifts made a
small dent in the orphan population.
Many
of those who made it to the U.S. express appreciation for their adoptive and
birth families, also recognizing the strength of their mothers, in giving them
up. One reoccurring issue that many faced while growing up in the U.S. was
related to their sense of identity. The majority were adopted by White American
families, which was also another source of criticism. Members of the African
American and Vietnamese American communities questioned the placement of the
majority of the children in White families.
These children often longed for a sense of belonging, evident in the
documentary films: Daughter from Danang and Operation Babylift . In both films, the
Baby lift children, now adults are compelled to return to Vietnam. Searching
for a connection to their familial roots and cultural identity, the one thing
that life in America could not offer them.
Golden
Children
The future was
bleak for the Vietnamese Amerasian children in Vietnam after 1975. They were a
reminder of a painful war to the Southern Vietnamese and a reminiscence of the
hated Americans to the Northerners. In Chung Hoang Chuong’s (1995) study of
Vietnamese Amerasians he found, “There was significant discrimination and
harassment in Vietnam after 1975 due to mixed parentage or an obvious
connection to the Americans”(Chuong p.66) Some Amerasian orphans, raised by
extended family reported being treated as servants. And Afro-Amerasian children
often faced ill-treatment and discrimination. Chuong found that later in life,
they were denied jobs or education because of their mixed heritage. They were left
to live in a society that holds a generally negative opinion of interracial relations.
(Chuong p.69) For those baring their father’s features, mixed race heritage was
impossible to conceal. Much like those
that made it to the U.S, many Amerasians in Vietnam, struggled with a sense of
belonging,
In 1987 the U.S. would enact the Amerasian
Homecoming Act, finally recognizing the children of U.S. Soldiers as Americans.
The Homecoming Act acknowledged the U.S.’s responsibility for the children. The
determination of whether to grant an individual access to the U.S. was based
solely on physical features, or looking “American”. The bill allowed for
Amerasians to bring their families with them to the U.S. When word of this
spread, Amerasian children became highly valued as a ticket to America,
and some were paid to falsely claim people as family. Children that were once
marginalized became very significant to those seeking passage to America. Sadly,
the stories of some Vietnamese dishonestly claiming Amerasians as their
family, cast a dark shadow over the Homecoming Act in the U.S. media.
The Baby lifts
remain a contentious issue. Some see them as a hopeful ending to an extremely
bleak war, a mission which provided great opportunity in America for thousands
of children .Others, question the U.S. Government’s motivation and see the
mission as a propaganda tool. If we analyze the voices of the orphans
themselves it is evident that their experiences are as complex as the war
itself. Identity issues troubled those
airlifted as well as those left to live in Vietnam. Brought into the world as a
product of war, they endured varying forms of hardship long after the airlifts
ended.
References
Chuong, Chung Hoang. The Amerasians from Vietnam: A
California Study. Southeast
Asia Community Resource Center. Web. 1 Apr. 2012.
Johnson, Kay.
"Children of the Dust." Time 13 May 2002. Time Inc. Web. 1 Apr. 2012.
Martin,
Allison.Vietnam Operation Babylift, Adopt Vietnam http://www.adoptvietnam.orgadoption/babylift-index.htm
Nguyen, Kien. The Unwanted: A Memoir. Boston:
Little Brown, 2001. Print.
Phan, Shandon. 2003. "Vietnamese Amerasians in
America" Asian-Nation:
The Landscape of Asian America.
<http://www.asian-nation.org/amerasians.shtml> (April 20, 2012)
Sachs, Dana. The Life We Were Given: Operation
Babylift, International Adoption, and the Children of War in Vietnam.
Boston, MA: Beacon, 2010. Print.
Statement on the Immorality of Bringing
South Vietnamese Orphans to the United States, April 4, 1975, Viola W. Bernard Papers, Box
62, Folder 8, Archives and Special Collections, Augustus C. Long Library,
Columbia University. http://darkwing.uoregon.edu/~adoption/archive/SIBSVOUS.htm
"The
Orphans: Saved or Lost?." Time,
105.16 (1975): 14.
Tsongas, Paul E.,
"Statement by U. S. Representative Paul Tsongas concerning Vietnamese orphans situation, April 5, 1975" (1975).
Position Statements. Paper 31.
Zigler, Edward. "The Vietnamese Children's
Airlift: Too Little and Too Late." , (1975):
No comments:
Post a Comment